Your insurer found an accident that wasn’t yours? Check your CLUE report
You are shopping for car insurance when an agent mentions an accident you do not recognize. Or a payment involving a vehicle you never owned. Before accepting the quote, ask where that record came from. If the source is CLUE, you can inspect and dispute it.
What CLUE actually is
LexisNexis maintains this insurance claims history. It is not your credit score or a DMV record. Auto claims can remain in the report for up to seven years. You can request one free report every 12 months. [1] A higher premium alone does not prove a CLUE error.
Ask before you argue
Request the event date, vehicle, reporting insurer, payment and data source in writing. Save the quote. A traffic violation may come from a different report; fixing CLUE does not automatically fix DMV records.
CLUE belongs to LexisNexis; A-PLUS is a separate Verisk system. If you receive an adverse action notice, request your free report from the company named there, not automatically from LexisNexis. [5] [6]
Get the report, then check the details
Use the official LexisNexis Consumer Center, select Request Your Consumer Disclosure Report, and complete its identity verification. Other privacy options on the page are not substitutes for this request. Keep the resulting personal information out of public chats and comments. [2]
Identity-check clarification: to obtain a copy of your report, the current LexisNexis online form requires either an SSN or a driver’s license number and issuing state. Provide these details only through an official secure LexisNexis channel, not in comments or public chats. If you lack these documents or verification fails, ask the Consumer Center which documents it accepts. Phone and mail requests do not bypass identity verification. Source: official form [2] and LexisNexis Printable Request Form Instructions.
Compare each unfamiliar entry with your policies and insurer correspondence: identity and vehicle, loss date and type, claim number, insurer, payment, status, and possible duplicate entries.
A $0 payment is not proof of an error. A genuine claim closed without payment can still be reported. Asking generally about coverage differs from reporting an actual loss. Do not conceal an incident your policy requires you to report. [3]
Dispute a specific error
Identify the exact entry and explain what is wrong. Attach relevant copies, such as the insurer’s correction letter, vehicle sale documents, or claim correspondence. Follow the dispute instructions in your report and contact the insurer that supplied the information. Keep the case number and submission date.
LexisNexis describes reinvestigating with the data source, then mailing the outcome and an updated file. [4] Read that response rather than assuming the record was deleted.
Illustrative example: a payment is attached to a VIN that is not yours. Write “I dispute claim [number/date] because the vehicle is not mine,” and provide supporting evidence, rather than asking to erase all unfavorable history.
After a correction
Send confirmation to the company quoting your policy:
“I disputed an inaccurate claim in my C.L.U.E. report. Please review the corrected report and confirm whether it changes my quote.”
A correction does not guarantee a lower premium or a refund. Compare quotes using the same coverage limits and deductible.
You can browse Job4Migrants services when looking for help. Check an agent’s state license and auto-insurance specialty; not every insurance professional handles car coverage.
Do this first: ask for the source of the disputed record and request your report. You do not need to pay someone promising to “clean” your insurance history.
Sources
[1] CFPB — LexisNexis C.L.U.E. & Telematics OnDemand (updated May 20, 2025).
[2] LexisNexis — Request Your Consumer Disclosure Report.
[3] Connecticut Insurance Department — CLUE FAQs.
[4] LexisNexis — Dispute procedure (PDF).
Checked November 17, 2026.
